Skip to main content

Is an AI scribe a medical device under EU MDR?

Is an AI scribe a medical device under EU MDR? What Article 2(1), Rule 11 and Sweden's 2026 finding mean for Irish consultants, and what to ask a vendor.

Ask Brigid Team · 9 min read

Researched and written by Ask Brigid's AI pipeline and published automatically — not individually reviewed by a person. Useful as a starting point; check clinical, legal and regulatory details against a primary source before relying on them.

Ask Brigid is practice software built for speed. Brigid Clinical Intelligence takes on the admin, and patients pay by card through a link.

It depends on what the manufacturer says the scribe is for. Under EU MDR, software is a medical device only when its intended purpose is medical. A tool that only produces a transcript is generally outside that line. But European regulators are now treating scribes that write clinical notes more strictly: in 2026, Sweden's Medical Products Agency found that a scribe whose notes feed later care should be at least Class IIa.

For an Irish private consultant, the practical point is simple. Before a scribe listens to a patient, find out what the vendor claims, which class it holds, and who checked it.

This article explains public guidance. It is not legal or regulatory advice.

How EU MDR decides whether software is a device

Two documents do most of the work.

The first is Article 2(1) of the Medical Device Regulation. A product, including software, is a medical device if the manufacturer intends it for a medical purpose such as diagnosis, monitoring, treatment or prediction of disease. Ireland's HPRA says the same on its qualification and classification page: a device must have a medical purpose, and software can meet the definition.

The second is the European Commission's MDCG 2019-11 rev.1, updated in June 2025. It says software must have a medical purpose on its own to qualify, and that "the intended purpose, as described by the manufacturer" is what counts. Simple record search does not qualify. Software that creates or modifies medical information for a medical purpose may.

So the same speech-to-text engine can sit on either side of the line. What decides it is what the vendor claims, and what the product actually does with the words.

If it is a device, which class?

Software devices are classified under Annex VIII, Rule 11. In plain terms:

Rule 11 sub-ruleWhat it coversClass
11aInformation used to take decisions with diagnostic or therapeutic purposesIIa, or IIb/III if a wrong decision could cause serious or irreversible harm
11bMonitoring physiological processesIIa, or IIb for vital parameters
11cAll other device softwareI

MDCG 2019-11 adds that sub-rule 11a "is generally applicable to all MDSW" with a medical purpose. That matters, because Class I can be self-declared by the manufacturer, while Class IIa and above need a notified body to assess the product.

What Sweden's regulator found in 2026

Early in 2026, Sweden's Medical Products Agency ran a market surveillance initiative on AI scribes. Its preliminary report on Tandem Health found that classing Tandem's scribe as Class I was "not compatible with EU MDR". The agency's reasoning, as Tandem published it on 27 May 2026:

  • The finished note is used as the basis for decisions in continued care, not just the current visit.
  • The scribe structures and infers clinical information, rather than only transcribing.
  • Classification does not depend on whether the clinician decides before or after the note is finalised.

Two caveats. Tandem is not a neutral party, and says so in the same post. And the definitive report was still pending when Tandem published. Still, the reasoning rests on EU MDR and MDCG 2019-11, which apply in every member state, Ireland included.

The UK says something different

On 29 July 2026, the UK's MHRA published guidance on ambient voice technology. According to Covington's summary, it says a scribe intended only to transcribe, summarise a consultation, prepare a letter for review or suggest codes for review is not a medical device. Features that suggest diagnoses or treatment, or that file notes and place orders without clinician review, are.

That guidance applies in Great Britain. A consultant in Dublin, Cork or Galway works under EU MDR. As of 9 November 2026, we did not find an HPRA statement specific to AI scribes, so the EU guidance above is the reference point.

Where the scribes sold in Ireland say they stand

We only report what each vendor publishes. Check again before you sign, because these positions are moving.

  • Tandem Health. Its data and security page says the AI Scribe, Coding Assistant and Clinical Decision Support are independently assessed and certified under EU MDR as Class IIa medical devices, and shows a CE mark with the number 3022.
  • Heidi Health. Heidi's Product Terms say that unless Heidi expressly states a regulatory classification for a product in your region, its products are administrative support tools and are not supplied as medical devices. Its scribe section says Scribe "is not a clinical decision-making tool". Heidi's help article on Evidence in the UK and EU says in-session Evidence is switched off for UK and EU accounts, because with patient context it would be clinical decision support.

For how each compares with practice software, see Ask Brigid vs Tandem Health and Ask Brigid vs Heidi Health.

Seven questions to ask any scribe vendor

Device status is the manufacturer's job, not yours. But you choose what records your patients, so ask these before the first clinic:

  1. Is the product a medical device under EU MDR, and in which class?
  2. Which legal entity holds the certificate, and which notified body issued it?
  3. What is the exact intended purpose in the instructions for use?
  4. Which features does the certificate cover: the note, coding, clinical suggestions, letters?
  5. Is it a CE mark under EU MDR, or only a UK registration?
  6. Can anything reach the patient record without a clinician reviewing it first?
  7. If the vendor says it is not a device, which features does it keep switched off in the EU to stay that way?

Get the answers in writing. Consent is a separate question: our guide to recording consultations and patient consent in Ireland covers it, and the EU AI Act Article 50 guide covers labelling AI output.

Where Ask Brigid stands

Ask Brigid is practice management software for Irish private consultants, not a stand-alone scribe. Its medical device page sets out its position in full. In short:

  • The intended purpose is administrative: clinic administration, records workflow, booking, billing and staff-authored documents.
  • No EU MDR CE mark is held or claimed. A determination recorded on 10 September 2026 is the manufacturer's position, not an HPRA decision.
  • The note assistant, declared on 28 September 2026, is still being assessed under Article 2(1) and MDCG 2019-11. The September determination does not yet cover it.
  • The note assistant's instructions rule out diagnosis, triage, clinical coding and any recommendation the clinician did not already make. Nothing becomes the record until the clinician signs it.

Consult dictation is on both live plans, Essential at €129 and Professional at €299 a month before VAT, with every seat included. Primary records are hosted in AWS Dublin (eu-west-1).

Frequently asked questions

Is an AI scribe a medical device under EU MDR?

It depends on the manufacturer's intended purpose. Software is a medical device only if that purpose is medical under MDR Article 2(1). A tool that only transcribes is generally not. But in 2026 Sweden's Medical Products Agency found that a scribe whose notes go into the record and inform later care should be at least Class IIa.

What class is an AI scribe under EU MDR?

If it qualifies as a device, Annex VIII Rule 11 applies. Software that provides information used for diagnostic or therapeutic decisions is Class IIa or higher. Class I is only for device software whose output is not used for those decisions and does not monitor physiological processes.

Is Tandem Health CE marked?

Tandem's data and security page says its AI Scribe, Coding Assistant and Clinical Decision Support are certified under EU MDR as Class IIa medical devices, and shows a CE mark with the number 3022. Tandem says the scribe gained Class IIa on 21 May 2026.

Is Heidi Health a medical device in the EU?

Heidi's Product Terms say that unless Heidi expressly states a classification for a product in your region, its products are administrative support tools and are not supplied as medical devices. Heidi also switches off in-session Evidence for UK and EU accounts. Ask Heidi in writing what applies to your account.

Does the UK MHRA guidance apply in Ireland?

No. The MHRA's July 2026 guidance on ambient voice technology covers products placed on the market in Great Britain. Ireland applies EU MDR, with the HPRA as the competent authority.

Is Ask Brigid a medical device?

Ask Brigid is practice management software with an administrative intended purpose. It holds and claims no MDR CE mark. Its note assistant is still being assessed under Article 2(1) and MDCG 2019-11, as its medical device page explains.

Your next step

This week, send the seven questions above to any scribe vendor you use or are trialling, and keep the reply with your practice records. If you'd rather see dictation inside the practice system itself, explore the sample practice: it's the real app on invented data, with no sign-up.

Ask Brigid is looking for a small number of founding consultant practices. Request early access and we will reply with current availability and the next step.

Ask Brigid takes the admin so the clinic day stays clinical.

For private consultants

Leave when your last patient does.

Practice software built for speed. Brigid Clinical Intelligence takes on the admin, and your team approves every step.

See Ask Brigid for consultants How to choose practice software

Ask Brigid. The evening is yours.

We’re early. No practice is using it yet. Open the sample practice and see a whole day working: invented patients, no sign-up.

David Galvin built Ask Brigid after watching his father, a consultant, lose his evenings to letters. Read why he built it, or write to him at david@askbrigid.com.